Maximizing Stock Investment Returns: How to Choose Between Value, Growth, and Dividend Strategies

TradingKey - In the field of stock investing, investors often face a core question: How can they find an investment path that aligns with their personal goals while dynamically balancing risk and return?

Among the mainstream strategies, value investing, growth investing, and dividend investing each offer unique stock selection methods and portfolio management approaches, making them essential choices for many investors.

The essence of value investing is akin to shopping at a discount mall: while others focus on the product packaging (short-term stock prices), you examine the intrinsic value of the product itself.

The belief is that stock prices fluctuate around their intrinsic value, and when a stock price falls below its intrinsic value, an investment opportunity arises.

How to Determine if a Stock is Suitable for Value Investing?

Value investing typically involves a detailed analysis of various financial metrics, including several commonly used indicators:

Price-to-Earnings Ratio (P/E) – Buying earnings at a “value”

The P/E ratio is the stock price ÷ Earnings Per Share (EPS), reflecting how much investors are prepared to pay for each dollar of earnings generated by the company.

For example, if Company A has a stock price of 20 yuan and an EPS of 2 yuan, its P/E ratio would be 10; while Company B has a stock price of 30 yuan and an EPS of 3 yuan, also resulting in a P/E ratio of 10.

However, if Company A is a stable consumer stock and Company B is a highly volatile tech stock, Company A may be considered "cheaper."

Note: Different industries have significant variations in P/E ratios—banking stocks have an average P/E ratio of around 8, whereas tech stocks can be as high as 30. Cross-industry comparisons with P/E ratios can lead to pitfalls.

Price-to-Book Ratio (P/B) – Buying assets at a “discount rate”

The P/B ratio = Stock Price ÷ Book Value Per Share, which is suitable for evaluating "asset-heavy" companies (such as banks or real estate).

For instance, if a bank has a book value per share of 5 yuan and its stock price is 4 yuan, the P/B ratio would be 0.8—meaning you are purchasing its assets at a “20% discount.”

However, for internet companies (whose assets primarily consist of code and talent rather than appearing on balance sheets), the significance of the P/B ratio diminishes.

Dividend Yield – Buying stocks that provide returns

Dividend yield = Annual Dividend ÷ Stock Price.

For example, if a stock priced at 100 yuan pays an annual dividend of 10 yuan, it yields 10%. Companies with high dividend yields typically have stable cash flows (such as utilities or leading consumer firms), making them suitable for conservative investors.

However, it’s important to note: that a high dividend yield does not necessarily indicate that it's worth buying.

It may represent a “trap” created by falling stock prices (for instance, if a company’s share price drops from 100 to 50 yuan while maintaining the same dividend amount of 5 yuan—the dividend yield increases from 5% to 10%, but the company's fundamentals may have deteriorated).

(Source: Freepik)

Growth investing primarily focuses on investing in the stocks of companies expected to grow at rates higher than the average for their industry or the overall market.

This approach emphasizes companies with rapidly increasing revenues or earnings, often based on future potential rather than current valuations.

What Dimensions Are Used to Assess Growth Potential?

Revenue Growth Rate – Accelerating Beyond Industry Averages

A continuous revenue growth rate of over 20% for three consecutive years is a fundamental threshold.

For example, if the average growth rate in the electric vehicle industry is 30% and a particular company achieves 50%, it indicates that this company is capturing market share from its competitors.

Note: It’s important to distinguish between "industry tailwinds" and "company capabilities."

For instance, during the pandemic in 2020, many healthcare stocks surged, yet some companies merely followed the trend and experienced plunging growth rates post-pandemic.

Net Profit Growth Rate – Genuine Profit Without Inflation

Is revenue growing fast but with low net profit margins? This scenario might suggest a potential "selling at a loss" condition.

For example, if an e-commerce platform's revenue rises by 40%, but it only has a 2% net profit margin and relies on financing to maintain operations, this kind of “burning cash for growth” carries extreme risks.

True growth stocks necessitate simultaneous increases in both "revenue and net profit."

What Are the Traps in Growth Investing?

High Volatility – The Roller Coaster of Emotions

Growth stocks behave like fighter jets in the stock market—they can soar sky-high when rising but may also plummet vertically when falling.

For instance, a leading clean energy stock might rise by 300% within a year in 2021 but then fall by 60% in 2022 due to overcapacity issues.

This volatility stems from rapid market adjustments to "future expectations"—if performance falls short of expectations, P/E ratios could drop from 100 to 30, leading to significant declines in stock price.

Pseudo-Growth – Beware of “The Emperor's New Clothes”

Financial “False” Growth:

Companies may use one-time asset sales or accounting policy adjustments to inflate short-term revenues. For example, if a company sells a building resulting in skyrocketing revenues while its core business is declining.

Misjudging Industry Cycles:

Mistaking “cyclical growth” for “sustainable growth.”

(Source: Freepik)

Dividend investing is an investment strategy primarily aimed at generating stable cash flow, with a strong focus on dividend yield.

How to Select Dividend Stocks?

Dividend Yield = Annual Dividend ÷ Stock Price

Generally, a dividend yield of 4%-6% is considered normal.

For example, if a bank’s stock price is 5 yuan and it pays an annual dividend of 0.25 yuan, the dividend yield would be 5%, which is higher than many other investment products.

However, it’s important to note that a dividend yield over 8% may be a “danger signal.”

For instance, a certain real estate company's yield had reached 10% before it collapsed; this was essentially due to plummeting share prices and debt-funded dividends.

Dividend Payout Ratio = Dividends ÷ Net Profit

A reasonable range for the payout ratio is between 30%-70%. A very low ratio may indicate that the company is stingy (for example, tech companies focused on R&D may have low payout ratios). Conversely, a very high ratio could impact growth (e.g., if a company's payout ratio is 100%, it indicates that they do not plan to reinvest in expanding production, raising concerns about future growth).

Years of Consecutive Dividends

Prioritize companies that have paid dividends for over five consecutive years, preferably with annual increases.

What Are the Risks of Dividend Investing?

High Leverage

Some companies maintain high dividends by borrowing money.

For example, consider a chemical firm with a debt ratio of 80% that chooses to maintain a payout ratio of 70%.

This may appear generous but can lead to financial distress as they are essentially “robbing Peter to pay Paul.” If industry cycles decline (such as falling product prices), cash flow can dry up and dividends can be cut suddenly, causing stock prices to plummet.

“Value Trap” – The Illusion of High Yield

A declining stock price can inadvertently increase the dividend yield.

For instance, if a consumer stock falls from 20 yuan to 10 yuan while maintaining its dividend at 1 yuan per share, its yield rises from 5% to 10%. However, if the company’s performance continues to deteriorate year after year, this “high yield” turns out to be misleading.

Be Cautious of Industry Cycles

Cyclical stocks (such as those in steel and coal) may offer exceptionally high dividend yields during prosperous periods but could suspend dividends or even incur losses during downturns.

Dividend investors should avoid industries that are heavily reliant on external factors and favor sectors with stable demand—such as utilities.

(Source: Freepik)

So how do you choose among these different stock investment strategies? Remember one core principle: your risk tolerance, investment goals, and holding period determine how well a strategy fits your needs.

Choose a Strategy Based on Risk Tolerance

Conservative Investors – Prioritize Stability; Avoid High-Stakes Games

If watching your account fluctuate keeps you awake at night, or if your invested capital consists of funds meant for retirement, it’s advisable to focus on value investing and dividend investing.

Value investing is akin to buying “discounted branded goods.”

For example, if consumer stocks are down and the P/E ratio of a leading liquor brand drops from 30 to 20 (below its historical average), you know that its brand strength remains intact; it’s simply undervalued due to market sentiment.

After purchasing, you can comfortably wait for the value to return while facing much less volatility compared to growth stocks.

Dividend investing feels like receiving “a paycheck every month.”

For instance, by holding shares in utility companies that offer a 4% annual dividend, even if the stock price declines, you still receive dividends without significant psychological pressure.

Aggressive Investors – If You Can Handle Volatility, Pursue High-Growth Opportunities

If you’re comfortable accepting a short-term loss of 20% without panic and plan to invest for over five years, then growth investing may work better for you.

For instance, while valuations in the AI industry are currently high, if a particular company possesses core algorithms expected to triple its revenue over three years, you'd be willing to invest based on this anticipated future growth.

Choose a Strategy Based on Investment Goals

Short-Term Goals (within 1 year)

Are you seeking ways to quickly generate additional income? Avoid relying on growth stocks' promises of future returns; instead, focus on "bargain hunting" opportunities within value investments or stable dividends from dividend stocks.

Long-Term Goals (3 years or more)

Aiming for wealth accumulation? A dual approach to growth and value investing is ideal.

Growth stocks: Consider sectors like renewable energy or biotechnology. For example, Tesla (NASDAQ: TSLA) was still posting losses in 2019 but returned a remarkable profit of 20 times its original investment by 2023 due largely to “industry transformation + company evolution.”

Value stocks: Invest in enduring sectors like food and beverages—industries that will always be in demand.

Choose a Strategy Based on Investment Horizon

Short-Term (1-3 months)

Market panic often leads to cases of "wrongful pricing."

For example, if a leading consumer stock drops by 15% due merely to quarterly results slightly below expectations while overall annual performance continues growing at 10%, it could represent an excellent buying opportunity. Purchasing during this dip and selling after earnings reports are released one month later when prices rebound could prove profitable.

This form of "bargain hunting" requires quick entry and exit strategies and suits investors who are sensitive toward market sentiment.

Long-Term (5 years or more)

Growth equities need time for companies to innovate and experiment effectively. Growth firms require time not only to overcome technological hurdles but also expand market share significantly.

Similarly, value investments may also take time as they await stock prices' gradual reversion or appreciation.