tradingkey.logo

American Financial Group Inc

AFG
138.340USD
+0.790+0.57%
Close 10/10, 16:00ETQuotes delayed by 15 min
11.54BMarket Cap
15.10P/E TTM

American Financial Group Inc

138.340
+0.790+0.57%
TradingKey Stock Score
Overall Financial Health
Valuation Dimensions
Earnings Forecast
Price Momentum
Institutional Confidence
Risk Assessment
Peer Comparison
TradingKey Stock Score
Overall Financial Health
Valuation Dimensions
Earnings Forecast
Price Momentum
Institutional Confidence
Risk Assessment
Peer Comparison

TradingKey Stock Score of American Financial Group Inc

Currency: USD Updated: 2025-10-13

Key Insights

The company's fundamentals are relatively stable. Its valuation is considered fairly valued,and institutional recognition is very high. Over the past 30 days, multiple analysts have rated the company as a Hold. Despite an average stock market performance, the company shows strong technicals. The stock price is trading sideways between the support and resistance levels, making it suitable for range-bound swing trading.

American Financial Group Inc's Score

Industry at a Glance

Industry Ranking
79 / 110
Overall Ranking
341 / 4695
Industry
Insurance

Support & Resistance

No Data

Score Analysis

Current score
Previous score

Analyst Rating

Based on 6 analysts
Hold
Current Rating
136.400
Target Price
-0.84%
Upside Space
Data disclaimer: Analyst ratings and target prices are provided by LSEG for informational purposes only and do not constitute investment advice.

American Financial Group Inc Highlights

StrengthsRisks
American Financial Group, Inc. is an insurance holding company. Through the operations of Great American Insurance Group, the Company is engaged primarily in property and casualty insurance, focusing on specialized commercial products for businesses. The Company’s segments include property and casualty insurance and Other. The property and casualty insurance business includes specialty sub-segments: property and transportation, which includes physical damage and liability coverage for buses and trucks and other specialty transportation niches, inland and ocean marine, agricultural-related products and other commercial property coverage; specialty casualty, which includes primarily excess and surplus, executive and professional liability, general liability, umbrella and excess liability, and specialty financial, which includes risk management insurance programs for lending and leasing institutions, fidelity and surety products and trade credit insurance.
High Growth
The company's revenue has grown steadily over the past 3 years, averaging 19.28% year-on-year.
High Dividend
The company is a high dividend payer, with the latest dividend payout ratio of 89.18%.
Stable Dividend
The company has regularly paid dividends over the past 5 years, with the latest dividend payout ratio of 89.18%.
Overvalued
The company’s latest PE is 15.19, at a high 3-year percentile range.
Institutional Selling
The latest institutional holdings are 56.07M shares, decreasing 1.90% quarter-over-quarter.
Held by Joel Greenblatt
Star Investor Joel Greenblatt holds 115.11K shares of this stock.

Financial Health

Currency: USD Updated: 2025-10-13

The company's current financial score is 5.31, which is lower than the Insurance industry's average of 6.39. Its financial status is weak, and its operating efficiency is low. Its latest quarterly revenue reached 1.92B, representing a year-over-year increase of 2.02%, while its net profit experienced a year-over-year increase of 16.75%.

Score

Industry at a Glance

Previous score
5.31
Change
0

Financials

4.87

Key Metrics

Cash and cash equivalents
Total assets
Total liabilities
Free cash flow
No Data

Quality of Earnings

6.49

Operational Efficiency

5.74

Growth Potential

4.00

Shareholder Returns

5.45

American Financial Group Inc's Company Valuation

Currency: USD Updated: 2025-10-13

The company’s current valuation score is 5.38, which is lower than the Insurance industry's average of 7.34. Its current P/E ratio is 15.19, which is 7.50% below the recent high of 16.33 and 37.74% above the recent low of 9.46.

Score

Industry at a Glance

Previous score
5.38
Change
0

Valuation Dimensions

P/E
P/B
P/S
P/CF
Industry Ranking 79/110
No Data

Earnings Forecast

Currency: USD Updated: 2025-10-13

The company’s current earnings forecast score is 6.67, which is lower than the Insurance industry's average of 7.31. The average price target for American Financial Group Inc is 136.00, with a high of 155.00 and a low of 124.00.

Score

Industry at a Glance

Previous score
6.67
Change
0

Support & Resistance

No Data

Analyst Rating

Based on 6 analysts
Hold
Current Rating
136.400
Target Price
-0.84%
Upside Space
Strong Buy
Buy
Hold
Sell
Strong Sell

Peer Comparison

60
Total
5
Median
6
Average
Company name
Ratings
Analysts
American Financial Group Inc
AFG
6
Travelers Companies Inc
TRV
26
Progressive Corp
PGR
25
Allstate Corp
ALL
23
American International Group Inc
AIG
20
W R Berkley Corp
WRB
18
1
2
3
...
12

Financial Forecasting

EPS
Revenue
Net Profit
EBIT
No Data

Data disclaimer: Analyst ratings and target prices are provided by LSEG for informational purposes only and do not constitute investment advice.

Price Momentum

Currency: USD Updated: 2025-10-13

The company’s current price momentum score is 6.74, which is lower than the Insurance industry's average of 7.22. Sideways: Currently, the stock price is trading between the resistance level at 146.86 and the support level at 132.97, making it suitable for range-bound swing trading.

Score

Industry at a Glance

Previous score
6.54
Change
0.2

Support & Resistance

No Data

Indicators

The Indicators feature provides value and direction analysis for various instruments under a selection of technical indicators, together with a technical summary.

This feature includes nine of the commonly used technical indicators: MACD, RSI, KDJ, StochRSI, ATR, CCI, WR, TRIX and MA. You may also adjust the timeframe depending on your needs.

Please note that technical analysis is only part of investment reference, and there is no absolute standard for using numerical values to assess direction. The results are for reference only, and we are not responsible for the accuracy of the indicator calculations and summaries.

Indicators
Sell(2)
Neutral(2)
Buy(0)
Indicators
Value
Direction
MACD(12,26,9)
-2.402
Neutral
RSI(14)
41.231
Neutral
STOCH(KDJ)(9,3,3)
18.013
Sell
ATR(14)
3.023
High Vlolatility
CCI(14)
-223.866
Oversold
Williams %R
84.089
Oversold
TRIX(12,20)
0.231
Sell
StochRSI(14)
7.785
Oversold
Moving Average
Sell(3)
Neutral(0)
Buy(3)
Indicators
Value
Direction
MA5
142.676
Sell
MA10
144.914
Sell
MA20
143.606
Sell
MA50
137.788
Buy
MA100
131.365
Buy
MA200
129.356
Buy

Institutional Confidence

Currency: USD Updated: 2025-10-13

The company’s current institutional recognition score is 5.00, which is lower than the Insurance industry's average of 6.91. The latest institutional shareholding proportion is 67.23%, representing a quarter-over-quarter decrease of 23.08%. The largest institutional shareholder is The Vanguard, holding a total of 7.66M shares, representing 9.18% of shares outstanding, with 6.62% decrease in holdings.

Score

Industry at a Glance

Previous score
5.00
Change
0

Institutional Shareholding

No Data

Shareholder Activity

Name
Shares Held
Chg %
The Vanguard Group, Inc.
Star Investors
7.66M
-2.68%
BlackRock Institutional Trust Company, N.A.
6.21M
-3.77%
Lindner (Carl H III)
5.84M
+5.17%
Lindner (S Craig)
5.32M
+18.57%
Fidelity Management & Research Company LLC
4.91M
+31.06%
State Street Global Advisors (US)
2.70M
-4.14%
Victory Capital Management Inc.
2.63M
+10.82%
Charles Schwab Investment Management, Inc.
2.57M
+1.77%
American Financial Corp. (ESOP)
2.55M
-2.44%
Lindner (Stephen Craig JR)
1.90M
--
1
2

Risk Assessment

Currency: USD Updated: 2025-10-13

There is no risk assessment score for the company; the Insurance industry's average is 6.86. The company's beta value is 0.80. This indicates that the stock tends to underperform the index during upward trending markets but experiences smaller declines during downward trending markets.

Score

Industry at a Glance

Previous score
0.00
Change
0
Beta vs S&P 500 index
0.80
VaR
+2.32%
240-Day Maximum Drawdown
+20.33%
240-Day Volatility
+23.84%

Return

Best Daily Return
60 days
+2.69%
120 days
+3.26%
5 years
+17.85%
Worst Daily Return
60 days
-4.05%
120 days
-6.14%
5 years
-8.15%
Sharpe Ratio
60 days
+1.83
120 days
+1.04
5 years
+1.22

Risk Assessment

Maximum Drawdown
240 days
+20.33%
3 years
+23.67%
5 years
+25.47%
Return-to-Drawdown Ratio
240 days
+0.58
3 years
+0.13
5 years
+1.04
Skewness
240 days
-0.38
3 years
-0.51
5 years
+1.01

Volatility

Realised Volatility
240 days
+23.84%
5 years
+24.24%
Standardised True Range
240 days
+1.95%
5 years
+1.73%
Downside Risk-Adjusted Return
120 days
+140.17%
240 days
+140.17%
Maximum Daily Upside Volatility
60 days
+13.98%
Maximum Daily Downside Volatility
60 days
+13.31%

Liquidity

Average Turnover Rate
60 days
+0.58%
120 days
+0.62%
5 years
--
Turnover Deviation
20 days
+19.08%
60 days
+27.52%
120 days
+34.77%

Peer Comparison

Insurance
American Financial Group Inc
American Financial Group Inc
AFG
5.32 /10
Score
Financial Health
Valuation Dimensions
Earnings Forecast
Price Momentum
Institutional Confidence
Risk Assessment
Arch Capital Group Ltd
Arch Capital Group Ltd
ACGL
8.72 /10
Score
Financial Health
Valuation Dimensions
Earnings Forecast
Price Momentum
Institutional Confidence
Risk Assessment
Hci Group Inc
Hci Group Inc
HCI
8.65 /10
Score
Financial Health
Valuation Dimensions
Earnings Forecast
Price Momentum
Institutional Confidence
Risk Assessment
Essent Group Ltd
Essent Group Ltd
ESNT
8.61 /10
Score
Financial Health
Valuation Dimensions
Earnings Forecast
Price Momentum
Institutional Confidence
Risk Assessment
Renaissancere Holdings Ltd
Renaissancere Holdings Ltd
RNR
8.59 /10
Score
Financial Health
Valuation Dimensions
Earnings Forecast
Price Momentum
Institutional Confidence
Risk Assessment
Everest Group Ltd
Everest Group Ltd
EG
8.30 /10
Score
Financial Health
Valuation Dimensions
Earnings Forecast
Price Momentum
Institutional Confidence
Risk Assessment
View more
KeyAI