Retail investors’ crypto enthusiasm clashes with ETF pain zone near US$89,600

Retail traders who jumped into Bitcoin ETFs this year are now facing pressure as Bitcoin falls back toward the level that many of them bought in at.

The entry point that matters here is around $89,613, which is the blended price where the average U.S. spot Bitcoin ETF investment sits, according to Bloomberg.

That $89,613 has now become the line where gains turn into losses for the everyday buyers who entered during the heavy inflows earlier in the year after Trump’s second inauguration.

Billions moved into these ETFs throughout the year. That demand helped lift Bitcoin to a new record high before the recent drop. But the coin is now down more than 20% from its peak.

Most ETF buyers are still above break-even, but the cushion is getting smaller. This same level also lined up with a reversal in April when Bitcoin hit its low of the year and then bounced higher.

Vetle Lunde, the head of research at K33, said, “It was very interesting to see how the April reversal coincided with the cost basis.”

Many ETF buyers didn’t buy the top. They added exposure during that selloff. If Bitcoin tests that zone again, those positions could quickly turn negative.

ETF participation grows while volatility returns

Supporters of Bitcoin ETFs have argued that these products bring in more patient investors. They say people using ETFs are less likely to trade on every price swing and are more comfortable holding through corrections.

They also argue that ETF flows have reduced some of Bitcoin’s extreme volatility. But the recent drawdown is showing that volatility has not disappeared.

Newer investors who entered through regulated ETF products are learning that the price of Bitcoin can still move sharply, even with Wall Street in the picture.

Market sentiment has weakened. Bitcoin fell more than 6% on Tuesday and traded under $100,000, its lowest level since June.

The coin is now down 20% from the high it reached last month, which in traditional markets would count as a bear market move. Ether and smaller altcoins have fallen even harder.

A large part of the selloff is tied to low market participation and fear left over from the October liquidation event that wiped out billions in leveraged positions and left long traders with little momentum to defend recent gains.

BlackRock’s IBIT ETF remains the largest Bitcoin ETF, pulling in more than $27 billion this year and holding around $85 billion in assets. But even with major asset managers involved, Bitcoin remains a market that moves in cycles.

James Seyffart at Bloomberg Intelligence said, “This asset and these ETFs move forward in this two-steps-forward one-step-back move.” He added that crypto remains a very volatile asset class and there is no certainty whether this is a small retracement or the beginning of a larger downturn.

Hedging rises as Bitcoin moves with tech stocks

Options traders have been preparing for further declines. Put contracts expiring in late November with $80,000 strike prices are getting the most interest on Deribit, the crypto exchange owned by Coinbase.

That positioning suggests that traders are protecting themselves against deeper losses or are positioning to profit if Bitcoin falls toward that level.

Bitcoin’s drop this week is also moving in line with the performance of high-growth tech stocks. Companies tied to AI trends, such as Palantir and Nvidia, have seen their share prices fall as traders question whether valuations became too stretched.

Bitcoin has often been viewed as a proxy for speculative appetite. It is now once again trading in sync with the mood of the wider equity market instead of acting as a hedge or separate alternative.

Get $50 free to trade crypto when you sign up to Bybit now